David Weber is making his bid for a legacy amongst the great science fiction authors of the past with his new novel Off Armageddon Reef. If you read the publisher advertising copy and the pull quotes on the back of the book, it is being billed as the epic of the decade; on-line reviews have compared this novel to Foundation, Dune, and the Wheel of Time.
I think people might be waxing a bit enthusiastic.
Don’t get me wrong, Off Armageddon Reef is an excellent book. Weber has constructed a book that is nearly impossible to put down. It is tightly plotted and complicated (a prerequisite for a good, deep read these days, it seems) with a cast of characters are much more than they seem. My first, honest read was that most of the characters were cardboard cut-outs until Weber spent more time in the last half of the book from each viewpoint, giving readers a clue about the motivations of the “bad guys” as well as the “good.”
The basic premise of the novel is that humanity has been wiped out in a terrible war with an alien species known as the Gbaba. As an act of desperation, two vast colony ships and the remaining fleet are sent far away from the territory that Earth used to control. Led by a group of visionary sociologists and psychologists, the fleet terraforms a world beyond the boundaries of the conflict. Knowing that developing technology will eventually lead humanity to destruction, the leaders of the fleet create a religion with themselves as the prophets. The religion prohibits innovation, labeling such behavior as “sinful.” The entire colony is subjected to brain re-programming while in stasis so that when they awake, they are ready to believe in the new world order. Fast forward eight hundred years to a point where long-dead dissidents in the fleet have cached the consciousness of a brilliant young tactical officer in a hidden cavernand given her an android body as well as several tools of advanced technology. Her mission is to break the hold this religion has on a stagnant humanity and to prepare the last bastion of men to meet their destiny among the stars.
Weber deals well with the conflict of established religion against innovation. He effectively conjures historical images of a Catholic church protecting its perogatives through the use of governments and military force. Likewise, there are several characters that have strong historical parallels to the late portions of the Renaissance. Most of the book is written from a perspective deeply immersed in maritime combat, evoking the Master and Commander series. It is obvious that Weber is both passionate and proficient in writing detailed accounts of wet-navy battles. In fact, it could be said that the book suffers sometimes from too much detail.
Weber doesn’t neglect the political machinations that go on behind the scenes. It is here where the book may be at its weakest–the main antagonists are mentioned only in passing, associated with a monolithic religious institution that is specifically designed to inspire disgust in free-thinking readers. The games that the church rulers play bring other, more temporal forces to bear on the one innovating Kingdom bring other characters to the forefront. It is here that we see typical Weber: Honorable enemies serving dishonorable masters out of a sense of duty. It makes their inevitable defeat have a heavier emotional impact, but Weber has been using this technique since the first of the Honor Harrington novels.
As I said before, the book is excellent. Is it the epic of the decade? I’m not so sure. I’m not even sure I would call this Weber’s best work, since I have been thoroughly enjoying his Honor Harrington novels. To compare this to Dune and Foundation seems to be a stretch based on only reading one book. The naval themes don’t resonate quite so well with me as the space combat themes do, although the book reads like alternate history if you forget the “hook.” I’d like to see what he does with the rest of the series. Two more strong entries, delving more into the conflict between religion and science (one of my favorite themes), could launch this into the pantheon of must-read epics.
In the meantime, do yourself a favor and go buy this book.
Pete on February 27th 2007 in Book Reviews