I promised a report on Boskone, but it took a bit for me to put my notes together into something I wanted to talk about.
First of all, the con this year didn’t have as many valuable panels for an aspiring writer. In fact, although I attended sessions for most of the day on Saturday, I found that most of the information I was gleaning was anecdotal in nature and not practical, as it had been in years past.
Perhaps the best session that I attended was the one that that asked a tough question about military science fiction: i.e. is this sub-genre little better than “war porn?” The implication, of course, is that we are all voyeurs watching the death and destruction of humans, aliens, and equipment with a sort of malevolent glee without the work having any literary or redeeming value. I thought that the panel, which included David Weber (of Honor Harrington fame) did an admirable job of defining true military science fiction and differentiating it from “war porn.” Following Weber’s lead, the panel defined true, military science fiction to have literary value if:
- The human cost and the human consequences are elevated above the glory of war for war’s sake
- More than just the bad guys get killed
- Collateral damage is realistic and appropriate to story/setting
- Characters come through combat changed by their experiences
- Justification for war and/or combat is provided
Weber also had an very compelling anecdote. I’ll retell it in my own words, but please note that this story is completely his:
Weber knew a colonel who said that the second worst moment as a combat officer was holding a nineteen year old boy in your arms as he died. You’ve trained for an operation; you’ve rehearsed it a thousand times. Everything has gone perfectly, yet a boy lays in your arms and takes his last breath. Weber asked the colonel what the worst moment was, if that was the second worst. The colonel’s reply: “Realizing that this was the job that I was born to do.”
The room was quiet for a moment after that comment. His point was that any military fiction that captures that aspect of humanity during and after combat succeeds in achieving literary merit. It shows the rest of us who do not have that common experience what the price of war means in the things that matter most…human lives.
The rest of the conference was entertaining enough, but I found that session to be the one most worthy of a write-up.
Boston is a pretty town, but difficult to navigate if you’re not a native. For a Texas boy, public transit is a chancy way to travel, and walking to a restaurant in twenty degree weather seems a little iffy. (Has it even been twenty degrees in Dallas this year? I don’t think so.) I flew Northwest through Memphis both coming and going, and of the four legs of the flight, three were delayed (two for mechanical problems on the plane). I suppose being delayed for mechanical problems is better than an engine falling off the plane in mid-flight, but the cantankerous part of me wondered if the Northwest mechanics had a preventive maintenance schedule.
Airport security was annoying as usual. I take secret pleasure in making the TSA ask me to do things. I never take my laptop out of the bag, nor do I remove my shoes. I make them ask, and then I make them tell me why I have to do it. Most of the time, I get a pretty humorless response. At other times, I get moved to the side for additional screening (This is a process I find particularly amusing because it makes them get off their swivel chair and actually work! I also get to lecture them about Nazi Germany, Stalinism, and our constitution), but this time, I got a detailed answer from a well-meaning TSA staffer that told me how I could hide explosives in my shoes. I didn’t bother to mention to him that me and ten of my chemist friends could bring 3.3 ounces of “liquid” on a plane and cause serious damage, yet be within the arbitrary rules set by a bureaucrat with a brother-in-law in congress. I made my eyes appropriately large, looked frightened, and wondered if my mockery was lost on the poor tool of tyranny in front of me. Apparently it was.
Pete on February 23rd 2008 in Cons